***********************************************************************************************************************
On November 11, 2018, 26-year-old Jemel Roberson was working as an armed security guard at Manny’s Blue Room in Robbins, Illinois, when a shooting broke out inside the bar.
Several people were wounded during the initial shooting. Roberson, who was working security, pursued one of the suspected shooters outside and held him on the ground while armed as police began arriving.
Then a Midlothian police officer arrived.
The officer was Ian Covey, who was responding to reports of an active shooter.
Covey encountered Roberson in the parking lot with a gun. According to the later prosecutor’s review, Roberson was dressed in black and was holding another man on the ground while pointing his firearm in the direction of people leaving the bar and arriving police.
Covey ordered Roberson to drop his weapon and get down. Police dash-camera footage captured audio of the commands, although there was no body-camera footage from Covey because he was not wearing one. Covey then fired four shots, striking Roberson.
Roberson died shortly afterward.
But witnesses described the encounter differently.
Several people at the scene said they were shouting that Roberson was a security guard, and another security guard told investigators that he had also tried to identify Roberson to the responding officer. Witnesses also said Roberson was wearing clothing associated with his security job, although prosecutors later concluded that the markings were not readily visible to Covey from his position.
One witness, Adam Harris, told reporters:
“Everybody was screaming out, ‘He was a security guard.’”
That became one of the most controversial aspects of the case.
The Illinois State Police investigated the shooting, interviewing witnesses and reviewing videos, police communications, photographs and other evidence.
The investigation ultimately involved more than 100 witnesses.
In October 2020, Cook County State’s Attorney Kim Foxx’s office announced that Covey would not face criminal charges.
Prosecutors said the evidence was insufficient to support criminal charges and concluded that Covey’s use of deadly force was legally justified under the circumstances as the evidence established them. A separate review by the Illinois State’s Attorneys Appellate Prosecutor agreed that criminal charges were not appropriate.
The decision remains controversial because there were competing accounts of the final seconds.
The prosecution’s review found that Covey gave multiple commands before firing and that Roberson turned toward him while still holding a gun.
Witnesses and Roberson’s family, however, disputed aspects of that account, including whether the officer had enough information to know Roberson was a security guard and whether witnesses were warning him before he fired.
There is another important part of the story: the actual gunman who triggered the police response was not killed by police. Four people were wounded in the original shooting, while Roberson the armed security guard who had intervened was the person fatally shot by the responding officer.
Roberson’s family subsequently filed a federal wrongful-death lawsuit against the officer and the Village of Midlothian.
So the documented timeline is:
November 11, 2018: A shooting occurs at Manny’s Blue Room.
Roberson: Works security, confronts and restrains one of the suspected shooters.
Police arrive: Officer Ian Covey encounters Roberson holding a firearm.
Seconds later: Covey fires four shots, killing Roberson.
2019: Investigators release additional video and audio from the scene.
2020: Prosecutors announce that Covey will not face criminal charges.
The case therefore isn’t accurately summarized as simply “a police officer shot a security guard while everyone screamed that he was a security guard.” Those witness accounts are documented, but so is the prosecutor’s finding that Covey gave commands and reasonably believed he was confronting an armed person during a chaotic active-shooter scene.
What isn’t disputed is the outcome:
Jemel Roberson was 26 years old.
He was working security.
He was armed and had confronted a suspected shooter.
A responding police officer shot him.
And the officer was never criminally charged.
His name was Jemel Roberson.
********************************************************************************************************
On May 30, 2011, 22-year-old Raymond Herisse was killed during a chaotic police shooting on Miami Beach during Memorial Day weekend.